Wednesday, November 29, 2006

Giving out Ganguly's numbers!

By John Cheeran
If the chairman of national selection committee Dilip Vengsarkar and his colleagues Venkatapathy Raju (South Zone), Ranjib Biswal (East Zone), Sanjay Jagdale (Central Zone) and Bhupinder Singh (North Zone) take a look at Sourav Ganguly’s record in South Africa and pick him for the Test series on the basis of those runs, there would not be a graver injustice than that to truth.
The truth is that Ganguly of now is a ghost of his glory years.
He has struggled throughout his comeback bid in India as well as on English county circuit.
It would be an injustice to youngsters such as Tamil Nadu’s Badrinath, Delhi’s Gautam Gambhir, and even to West Bengal’s Jhunjhunwala, who batted much better than Ganguly in the last game the former Indian skipper played against Punjab in Mohali.
Here you can take a look at how Ganguly had scored in South Africa in the past two tours.
2001-2002 First Test Bloemfontein vs South Africa: Sourav Ganguly 14 and 30; Rahul Dravid (as an opener) 2 and 11, VVS Laxman 32 and 29
Second Test Port Elizabeth: Ganguly 42 and 4 (n.o.), Dravid 2 and 87, VVS Laxman 89
In One-dayers 1st match vs SA: Ganguly 127; Dravid 1; 2nd match vs SA : Ganguly 24, Dravid 54; 3rd match vs Kenya: Ganguly 24, Dravid 11; 4th match vs SA: Ganguly 85, Dravid 71; 5th match vs Kenya Ganguly 111, Dravid did not bat; Final vs South Africa: Ganguly 9, Dravid 77 (top scorer)
In 1996-97 First Test at Durban: Ganguly 16 and 0; Dravid 7 and 27 not out
Second Test Cape Town: Ganguly 23 and 30; Dravid 2 and 12 Third Test Johannesburg: Ganguly 73 and 60; Dravid 148 and 81
One-day series: Vs South Africa: Ganguly 40; David 8; vs Zimbabwe Ganguly 38, Dravid 23; vs South Africa Ganguly 0, Dravid 50; vs South Africa Ganguly 83, Dravid 53; vs Zimbabwe Ganguly 31, Dravid 12; vs Zimbabwe Ganguly 12, Dravid 17; Final vs South Africa Ganguly 5, Dravid 84 (top scorer).
This string of scores indicate Ganguly cracks under pressure in big games where as Dravid lifts his batting when going gets tough against quality opponents as he has proved in those two one-day finals against South Africa.
But the point is that whatever success Ganguly has achieved in the past does not make him a decent player now, deserving an India cap.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

good article- Based on your statistical data, your conclusion does sound right. I agree Badrinath has been denied a chance for a long time.

I have done similar statistical analysis to suggest the reasons for India's recent abysmal performance against South Africa- Its actually the toss.

Unknown said...

Great job. Nice stats. But I'm sorry to say, all your painstakingly compiled stats don't mean anything. Badri is a class player... but let's accept it... the pitches in SA are not just difficult... they are rank alien!!
Imagine handing over a mughlai specialist cook, a microwave oven... for the first time in his life... Poor guy won't even know which buttons do what! And knowing our selectors and fans, Badri's failure in SA could well mean the end of his international career... Take your memory 15 years back... The Royal Bengal Tiger, after a superb run in the Ranji was taken to Australia... One match...Just one match... and he was in the wilderness for the next five years... There was Jaggu to bring him back in the England tour then... and Sourav showed what a class player he was! Who is going to bring Badri back?
The solution, my friend, lies not in talent, for Raina, too is immensely talented... The solution lies in the pitches back home, that prepare the youngsters to drive tractors and send them off to pilot jets! The crash is inevitable... What we need are green top pitches, at least 4-5, where the budding talents are put to test and made to acclamatize before they enter the big arena... Yes, it will be a long, long process... But its got to start somewhere... Till then, it makes sense to send the old warhorses, who can at least, hopefully, put into use their experience and avoid repeating mistakes in the past, instead of scarring the confidence of talented youngsters and pack them off to oblivion!

Cheers,
Sree

Anonymous said...

Ganguly is back with a promising 83 in the practice match.What you tell now ? Please for heaven's sake don't write his selection was bad.

ജാലകം
 
John Cheeran at Blogged